Experiment 2 Effect of surfactants on surface tension

Goal

1
Understanding and visualising the effect of surface tension
2
Practising hands-on techniques for measuring surface tension.
3
Experimenting with and comprehending the effects of surfactants.

Background

We apply scientific methods and concepts to comprehend and manipulate physical properties in the natural world. One crucial property that impacts various systems is the surface tension of liquids.
In simplified terms, surface tension arises from molecular attractions observed at the interface between two bulk phases. The force at this interface results from intermolecular attractions within the liquid being stronger than those between liquid and air molecules. As a result, molecules at the liquid's surface are more attracted to those within the liquid than to those in the air (see figure below). This phenomenon causes the liquid's surface to behave like an elastic membrane, akin to a trampoline, striving to minimize its surface area and resist external forces.
Effect of surfactants on surface tension

What is a surfactant?

Surfactant is typically made up of 

  1. Polar parts that are attracted toward (and are soluble in water or liquid) are called hydrophilic and 
  2. Nonpolar parts that repel water (and are not soluble in water or liquid) are called hydrophobic. 

When surfactants, with both polar and nonpolar components, are introduced into a system involving opposing forces (such as air-water or oil-water interfaces), the hydrophilic groups migrate towards the water phase, while the hydrophobic groups move away from water and towards air or oil. This action reduces surface tension because now water can interact with both other water molecules and the hydrophilic (water-attracting) parts of the surfactant.

As a result, water molecules are no longer tightly bound to each other but can spread over a larger area. This effect can be observed when drops of water on a surface lose their dome-like structure upon the addition of a surfactant.

How do we measure

Surfactants are widely utilized, with one of their most common applications being in detergent solutions. Water exhibits relatively high surface tension compared to other liquids. Hence, in cleaning processes, it is crucial to lower surface tension so that water can spread and effectively wet surfaces, allowing it to adhere to and dissolve impurities for removal. Chemicals that achieve this effectively are known as surface active agents or surfactants, which are often referred to as making water “wetter.”

How do we measure surface tension?

One of the most commonly employed methods for measuring surface tension involves analyzing the shape of an axisymmetric droplet using drop-shape analysis. In this technique, a pendant drop suspended from the tip of a needle exhibits a shape influenced by both gravitational force and surface tension.

These forces act in opposition: gravity attempts to elongate the droplet, while surface tension endeavours to maintain its spherical form. By quantifying the gravitational force and observing the resultant droplet shape, we can calculate the surface tension of the liquid under examination.

Optimization of contact angle

Apparatus required

1 Syringe
2 Two 100mL Beaker
3 Detergent
4 Glass rod

Procedure

Step 1 - Fill the two beakers

Fill the two beakers with 75mL of water. Add 2mL of detergent into one of the beakers using a Syringe. Stir the detergent solution using a glass rod.

Step 2 - Open App

Open the Droplet Lab app on the Computer.

Step 3 - Set the density and needle diameter

Set the density and needle diameter as 0.998g/ml (Water Density) and 1.8mm (Needle used), respectively.

Step 4 - Fill the syringe with water

Fill the syringe with water. Lock the syringe in the syringe holder once it is filled. Tip: Make sure the position of the tip of the needle is in the middle of the live window of the screen as shown below.

 

Experiment 2: Effect of surfactants on surface tension

Step 5 - Slowly generate a drop with the syringe

Slowly generate a drop with the syringe. The ideal situation for drop measurement is to aim for when the drop is just about to detach from the needle tip.

Step 6 - Adjust the image quality

Adjust the image quality (including light condition and focus distance) using the two filters in the right-hand top corner. Once we have a suitable image click a picture by pressing the orange button in the center of the bottom edge.
i. Tip: If you cannot focus on the droplet or its blurry please move the syringe holder further from the phone.

 

Experiment 2: Effect of surfactants on surface tension

Step 7 - Calibrate the image

Calibrate the image of the drop.

Step 8 - Go into the measurement interface

Go into the measurement interface by clicking on the drop image. Drag the horizontal orange line into the middle of the needle.

Step 9 - Drag the 2 vertical red bars to the needle

Drag the 2 vertical red bars to the needle. And then click on the blue calibrate button besides the calculate button. Once the calibration is done, drag the horizontal line towards the contact point between the needle and the droplet.

Questions & Discovery

Which liquid do you think has the strongest molecular interactions? In other words, which liquid can hold onto itself the tightest?

Hint: Try watching a video of a water balloon popping in slow motion and observe its behaviour

Can you tell which of the following droplets A or B most resembles the drop from the spray of a car washer (with wash fluid)? And why?

Hint: Try watching a video of a water balloon popping in slow motion and observe its behaviour

The surface tension of pure water is 72.8 mN/m at 20 degrees C. Does this value match with your measurement value? If not, please give at least five reasons which cause the difference.

Hint: Try watching a video of a water balloon popping in slow motion and observe its behaviour

How does surface tension explain how rain comes down in droplets instead of in a sheet?

Hint: Try watching a video of a water balloon popping in slow motion and observe its behaviour

What will happen if you double the detergent concentration (i.e. Dissolve 4mL)? What about 20mL?

Hint: Try watching a video of a water balloon popping in slow motion and observe its behaviour

What may be the sources of errors in any measurement when using surfactants?

Hint: as an example, what would happen if you used the same syringe multiple times

In the case of detergents, why would you want to reduce the effectiveness of a surfactant?
Surfactants are also used in mechanical machines, explain why.
Explain if the system you used in this experiment can be used for water quality control.
Since surfactants can make water “wetter”, try thinking of a creative way to exploit this phenomenon; whether for practical purposes or amusement.
For what other purposes can you use this instrument? Explain how it can be used and what procedure would be applied.

Download Experiment